How to drive repeat purchases with a loyalty program

Robert Ĺšwietlicki
Robert Ĺšwietlicki
Senior Product Marketing Manager
repeat purchases - article cover
Market Insights

How to drive repeat purchases with a loyalty program

Learn how to boost repeat purchases with a well-designed loyalty program. Explore strategies for new users, active members, and at-risk customers. Discover best practices for customer-centric success.

In today's competitive business landscape, securing repeat purchases from your customers is essential for sustained growth and profitability. One effective tool to achieve this goal is a well-designed loyalty program. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore strategies and best practices to drive repeat purchases through a loyalty program. We'll delve into insights from our years of loyalty experience and real-world examples to help you create a program that fosters customer loyalty and boosts your bottom line.

Understanding the importance of repeat purchases

Before diving into loyalty program strategies, it's crucial to recognize the significance of repeat purchases. This metric is a key indicator of your program's success. Repeat purchases not only contribute to increased revenue but also solidify your customer base, leading to long-term profitability. After all, a well-designed and functioning loyalty program is one of the most effective tools to improve this metric.

Strategies for driving repeat purchases

To maximize the effectiveness of your loyalty program, it's essential to categorize your strategies based on different customer segments. We suggests dividing your efforts into three distinct categories, each with a unique set of needs and tactics:

  1. New users
  2. Existing active users
  3. and at risk members

Incentivizing repeated purchases among new users

Building relationships with new joiners

Building a strong relationship with new program members is crucial. One-time buyers pose a significant challenge for loyalty managers. Once a person joins the loyalty program, the initial period is the perfect opportunity to drive engagement and establish a meaningful connection. Building early engagement with new joiners is the key to converting them into loyal, repeat customers.

Strategies for New Users’ activation

When it comes to new users, your loyalty program should focus on establishing a strong foundation for long-term customer relationships. Here are some strategies to consider:

1. Personalized onboarding: Welcome new members with personalized messages and offers based on their initial purchase or interests. You can gather the necessary data via a welcome survey or based on the transactional information. This immediate customization can set the tone for a more engaging experience.

2. Educational content: Provide resources and content that help new users make the most of their membership. Whether it's tips on product usage or exclusive how-to guides, valuable information can enhance their overall experience.

3. Early engagement incentives: Encourage new users to engage with your brand by offering exclusive bonuses or rewards for their first few interactions. This not only increases the chances of repeat purchases but also lays foundations for a successful long term relationship.

4. Feedback gathering: Actively seek feedback from new members to understand their expectations and areas where your loyalty program can improve. Make them feel heard and valued from the outset.

Incentivizing repeated purchases among existing active users

Designing for long-term engagement

The core mechanism of your loyalty program should be designed to foster repeat purchases and long-term member engagement. Pay special attention to your active members, as they are more likely to continue purchasing if they've had a positive experience, including after-sales service.

Data-driven adaptation

Utilize customer data to customize program mechanisms to your industry and the products you sell. Consider the average frequency of purchases in your industry when designing your program's features.

Strategies for existing active users’ activation

For existing active users, your loyalty program should aim to strengthen their loyalty further. Here are some extended strategies to consider:

1. VIP treatment: Recognize and reward your most loyal customers with exclusive perks and privileges. This could include early access to new products, dedicated customer support, or invitation-only events.

2. Tailored recommendations: Leverage customer data to provide personalized product recommendations based on their past purchases. Help them discover new items they're likely to enjoy.

3. Gamification: Implement gamification elements within your loyalty program to make the experience more engaging. Challenges, badges, and competitions can keep active users excited and motivated.

4. Special events: Host special events or sales exclusively for active members. This not only drives repeat purchases but also creates a sense of belonging to an exclusive community.

Incentivizing repeated purchases among at risk members

Winning back lost customers

For customers classified as "at risk," it's vital to implement win-back campaigns. These campaigns should motivate users to complete a purchase and reignite their interest in your products or services.

Strategies for at risk members’ activation

At-risk members represent a valuable segment that, with the right approach, can be reengaged. Here are some extended strategies to consider:

1. Personalized reengagement: Craft personalized messages and offers aimed at addressing the specific reasons these customers became at-risk. Whether it's addressing product concerns or highlighting new features, tailor your communication.

2. Exclusive comeback offers: Provide compelling incentives for at-risk members to return, such as limited-time discounts, bonus points, or free trials of new products or services.

3. Feedback and recovery: Encourage at-risk customers to provide feedback on their previous experiences. Use this information not only to improve your loyalty program but also to rectify any past issues they may have encountered.

4. Re-engagement challenges: Create challenges or goals designed to bring at-risk members back into the fold. Offer rewards or discounts for reaching specific milestones or making repeat purchases.

Loyalty program strategies to drive repeat purchases

Now that we've outlined the three customer segments, let's explore specific strategies that can be effective in driving repeat purchases within each group.

Rewards

Well-designed rewards systems are fundamental for encouraging repeat purchases. Carefully plan the threshold for earning the first reward. It should be low enough to show members that it's achievable but high enough to encourage multiple transactions. This strategy is suitable for both new joiners and active members.

Tiers

Tiers within a loyalty program can be a powerful motivator for members. Not only do they encourage members to strive for higher tiers and unlock additional benefits, but they also motivate them to maintain their tier status. This approach is effective for new joiners and active members.

Discount for the next transaction

Offering discounts for the next purchase is a straightforward method to drive immediate repeat purchases. You can create a sense of urgency by time-limiting these discounts. However, be cautious, as excessive discounting can impact your profit margins. Tailor your discount offers to each customer segment.

  • New users: "Keep going! Here’s your 20% discount for the next purchase. Hurry up - it is valid only for 10 days."
  • Active users: "Make your next order by the end of the month and enjoy 15% off."
  • At risk users: "We miss you! Come back and enjoy 15% off at your next visit."

Offering complementary goods & services

Leverage user purchase history to offer complementary goods or services. These could include insurance, installation, configuration, and more. This strategy is versatile and suitable for all customer groups.

Bonus points & achievements

Implement bonus points and achievement challenges to reward customers for specific actions or behaviors. Ensure that the challenge rules are adapted to each segment's specifics. This strategy can be applied to all customer groups.

  • New users: "Welcome! Enjoy double points for all transactions during your first month!"
  • Active users: "Visit us 3 days in a row and get 50 bonus points."
  • At risk users: "Get 100 points on your next visit!"

Subscriptions

Subscription models can be highly effective in driving repeat purchases. These models lock in customers for a period, ensuring a consistent stream of revenue. Collaborate with your team to explore the potential of subscription offerings for your business.

Restore & refill offers

Use customer data to predict when a customer is likely to run out of a product and incentivize them to repurchase or stock up. Make it easy for customers to reorder with one-click options. This approach works well for various customer segments.

Test option

In some industries, particularly those with expensive products or low purchase frequencies, offering customers the chance to test a product before purchase can be a compelling strategy.

Best practices for driving repeat purchases

In the ever-evolving landscape of customer loyalty and business competition, adhering to best practices can be the key differentiator between a mediocre loyalty program and an exceptional one. Here, we delve deeper into the best practices that can significantly enhance the effectiveness of your loyalty program and solidify your brand's position as a customer-centric leader.

1. Utilize data-driven insights

One of the most potent tools at your disposal in today's digital age is data. Leverage it to its full potential. Automate communication and adapt strategies to specific customer segments based on their purchase history and habits. Tailoring your approach to each customer's preferences and behaviors not only enhances engagement but also shows customers that you understand their needs.

For instance, if you notice a customer consistently purchases a certain product, offer them exclusive deals or rewards related to that product. If another customer frequently browses but doesn't purchase, send them personalized recommendations to nudge them toward a conversion.

2. Industry adaptation and customization

No two industries are alike, and neither should your loyalty program strategies be. Tailor your loyalty program to suit your industry, taking into account the appropriate measurement periods for repeat purchases. Recognize the nuances of your sector, such as typical purchase frequencies and consumer expectations, and design your program accordingly.

For example, the repeat purchase cycle for a quick-service restaurant (QSR) will differ significantly from that of the automotive industry. Adapt your loyalty program's timing and incentives to match the unique characteristics of your industry.

3. Elevate the customer experience

In a world teeming with choices, the customer experience reigns supreme. The best motivation for customers to make repeat purchases is the exceptional experience they've had during previous interactions with your brand. Hence, prioritize delivering exceptional customer service at every touchpoint.

Ensure that your customer support is prompt, efficient, and empathetic. Monitor customer satisfaction through methods like Net Promoter Scores (NPS) and surveys to gauge how well your loyalty program is resonating with your audience. Set high standards for service and strive to exceed them consistently.

4. Continuous evaluation and evolution

As the market dynamics shift and consumer preferences evolve, your loyalty program should be dynamic and adaptive. Regularly review and refine your loyalty program strategies. Create a feedback loop that incorporates insights from customer feedback, sales data, and market trends.

Stay attuned to emerging technologies and industry best practices. Be ready to pivot and modify your program to stay ahead of the curve. What worked yesterday may not work tomorrow, so an ongoing commitment to refinement is crucial.

Incorporating these best practices into your loyalty program is not a one-time endeavor but an ongoing commitment to customer-centricity. By doing so, you'll not only drive repeat purchases and cultivate customer loyalty but also position your brand for long-term success and profitability. Remember, a well-executed loyalty program has the potential to be a game-changer, propelling your brand to new heights in the ever-competitive business landscape.

Closing remarks

The strategies we've explored in this comprehensive guide provide a roadmap for harnessing the full potential of your loyalty program, regardless of whether you're dealing with new joiners, active members, or those at risk of straying.

The importance of repeat purchases cannot be overstated. They not only contribute to your bottom line but also solidify your customer base and enhance your brand's reputation. With the right approach, you can transform occasional buyers into loyal advocates who keep coming back for more.

As you implement these strategies and best practices, remember that customer data is your ally. Leverage it to tailor your offerings and communications, ensuring that each customer feels valued and understood. Additionally, don't forget to adapt your loyalty program to your industry's unique dynamics, and always keep a finger on the pulse of customer satisfaction.

Lastly, embrace the idea that your loyalty program is a dynamic entity. Regularly evaluate and refine your strategies to stay relevant in a rapidly changing market. By doing so, you'll continue to drive repeat purchases and nurture long-lasting customer relationships.

Get a head start in designing your loyalty campaigns

Download our 10 market-proven loyalty campaign templates. Use these templates to drive more purchases and engage customers with leading loyalty practices!

Join the community of 1000+ Loyalty Builders

Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to acquire, engage, and retain your customers

Starbucks logoDisney logoMcDonald's logoVodafone logoadidas logo
Tell us about your challenges and we will together
Loyalty Program Trends 2025

200+ loyalty experts reveal trends, challenges, and strategies you can’t miss.

Download report

Table of contents

Success stories

See how Open Loyalty helps brands grow their business

limango

limango used gamification to drive user engagement and triple buying frequency
Banner - client Equiva

EQUIVA

EQUIVA doubled purchase frequency and saved EUR 68.000 with loyalty app-powered referrals

dacadoo

dacadoo’s digital health app boosted user activation by 62% with gamification