.png)
The Loyalty Program ROI Worksheet helps loyalty managers calculate the return on their loyalty program investment and track and evaluate the results of customer loyalty initiatives. It focuses on KPIs such as number of customers, purchase frequency, or average transaction value, providing a sharp overview of how the loyalty program increases engagement and sales.
By inputting your program data, you'll see how these efforts contribute to incremental revenue, customer retention, and overall program success. The worksheet also allows for comparisons with any baseline you choose – whether last year's results, the program's first year, or even a pre-loyalty scenario – so you can easily measure growth and ROI over time.
With an intuitive setup, this tool provides you with actionable insights that can be shared with stakeholders. All you need is your existing data, and you'll quickly be able to forecast future performance, pinpoint opportunities for improvement, and demonstrate the real impact your loyalty program is delivering.
This loyalty scheme ROI worksheet is designed for loyalty managers or teams handling customer loyalty programs.
Here’s how it works:
Overall, you can easily calculate ROI, but it’s also a handy tool for loyalty managers to track customer behavior, membership growth, and the value the loyalty program brings to your business. Note that loyalty managers have to enter these numbers manually, so it is necessary to track them in another tool to stay accurate. This way, you can maintain a comprehensive view of your program’s performance without missing a beat.
Disclosure!
Before you jump in, having all your data ready is super important. This means gathering info from different teams, like the accounting department, developers, and marketing. Teamwork is key here! You'll need to pull together insights from various sources to ensure your ROI analysis is spot-on. So, be prepared to do a little digging.
The Loyalty Program ROI Worksheet provides an upfront understanding of how your customer loyalty strategies influence sales and customer engagement levels.
It offers a snapshot of your program's performance, giving management a clear view of current realities. While the ROI is a byproduct of your analysis, this tool highlights the potential benefits and costs associated with your loyalty initiatives.
By simply inputting essential data like:
Only then you'll gain a solid understanding of how well your loyalty efforts are working and where you might need to tweak things.
Read the general rules for using the worksheet:
If you have a loyalty program:
You don’t need any extra data – simply use the information you already have from your existing program collected from your loyalty solution, or create predictive numbers based on your business expectations and market reality.
If you don’t have a loyalty program:
Start with the data you already have about your customers and sales. You can also create predictive numbers based on your business goals and market trends to guide your analysis.
It's all about confirming that your loyalty program is performing as it should and helping you communicate its successes (or areas for improvement).
This sheet focuses on input data (labeled as "Input data") for the current year or baseline (referred to as "Year 0").
The key section includes:
You can modify these input values to assess how different metrics impact the program's overall profitability.
This sheet also contains similar sections and further detailed calculations based on the initial input data from the "Calculator" sheet. Use this sheet to analyze the final outputs or ROI metrics.
In both sheets, there are empty or placeholder columns that allow room for expansion. Modify the values in the input sections to assess how customer behavior and transactional values will influence the program's success over time.
Open Loyalty
Loyalty expert with over 25 years of experience in building customer loyalty (B2B and B2C) in Europe. Paweł worked for over 21 years at BP as a loyalty manager and head of marketing on the Polish market, introducing BP partnerclub and multipartner Payback programs, and then for 5.5 years he used his knowledge in BP headquarters in Europe. He also worked for over 2 years in the e-commerce fashion industry as CRM and loyalty director at ANSWEAR.com As a loyalty expert at Open Loyalty, Paweł works for Open Loyalty clients, passing on his knowledge, skills, and support in creating successful loyalty programs.
Loyalty Point
Co-founder and Managing Partner of Loyalty Point, with over 20 years of leading award-winning loyalty programs for top brands in retail, finance, and B2C industries. Under his leadership, Loyalty Point has won numerous awards, including 10 Effie Awards, 23 Golden Arrow, 5 Loyalty Awards, 4 Loyalty Heroes, and more proving their expertise in driving loyalty program success. Przemysław’s deep focus on loyalty program strategies, audit and optimization, and customer-centric solutions has helped brands across multiple industries increase customer retention and lifetime value.
Loyalty Point
Co-founder and Managing Partner of Loyalty Point, a leader in the loyalty industry for over 10 years. Dominik has spearheaded some of the most successful and award-winning loyalty programs in Poland, with his agency earning 10 Effie Awards, 23 Golden Arrow, 5 Loyalty Awards, 4 Loyalty Heroes, and more. With a focus on building data-driven loyalty strategies and delivering exceptional customer experiences, Dominik and his team have worked with top brands in retail, finance, and FMCG to optimize their loyalty programs and boost customer retention.
A loyalty program's ROI, or return on investment, basically tells you how profitable your scheme is compared to what you're spending on it.
It's a way for companies like yours to see if the program is actually paying off and how quickly they can be achieved. Are you getting enough value through things like increased customer spending, better retention, and higher program engagement to justify the investment?
If the numbers look good, then your loyalty scheme is doing its job!
Loyalty schemes directly impact customer retention rate by encouraging repeat visits. Clients feel recognized and are more likely to come back, increasing their lifetime value. They also tend to spend more per visit because the incentives and rewards motivate them to add a bit more to their carts. On top of that, these programs can drive incremental sales – purchases that wouldn't have happened without the draw of earning points or claiming exclusive discounts.
One of the big wins here is reduced marketing costs. It's more affordable to engage existing customers through a scheme than to chase new ones with traditional marketing. You're working with people who already like your brand. Only by keeping buyers around, can you achieve a lower churn rate, saving the expense and effort needed to replace those lost customers.
Loyalty schemes give you access to data that's perfect for personalized marketing. Such data lets you target campaigns more precisely, leading to better conversion rates and more efficient spending. It's not just about marketing, though. The insights help with product and service optimization. Knowing what your audience prefers means you can tweak your offerings to better meet their needs.
Satisfied loyalty program members can become advocates for your brand. They share their positive experiences, bringing in new customers through word-of-mouth. And having a solid program helps with competitive differentiation. It sets your brand apart, attracting more clients and building a base that's likely to stick with you.
To calculate the ROI of a loyalty scheme, you can use the following formula:
Where:
Suppose a retail store implements a loyalty scheme with the following data:
This means the loyalty scheme generates a 300% return on investment, indicating it's a highly profitable venture for the business.
Understanding the return on investment for a scheme involves more than tracking business revenue and costs. Read about the several key factors that can significantly impact the success of your program in driving ROI.
How you structure your scheme and its value proposition can make or break its success. Think about everything from the types of rewards you offer to how easy it is for customers to redeem them.
So, are the rewards desirable enough to motivate customers? Is the process to earn and redeem points straightforward, or is it complicated and cumbersome?
If the program is too complex or the benefits aren't enticing, clients might not see the value and could lose interest quickly. A well-designed program should balance offering custom rewards and making it simple for customers to understand and participate.
For a loyalty scheme to truly drive ROI, clients need to be actively involved – this is mainly influenced by how compelling the incentives are.
Are they excited to earn points or rewards, and do they see it as a fun and valuable part of their shopping experience?
If the incentives are aligned with what your buyers really want, they're more likely to engage regularly. Try to offer exclusive discounts, special access to products, or personalized deals. The more you can keep people engaged with the program, the more likely they are to return and spend more, which directly impacts the program's ROI.
Learn how to work on customer activation and increase brand stickiness among program members.
Setting up and maintaining a loyalty scheme involves several costs, including the technology platform, marketing efforts to promote the program, the actual rewards given to clients, and ongoing maintenance to keep everything running smoothly.
Is the investment you're making into the program balanced by the value it’s generating?
Definitely consider the ongoing expenses when evaluating ROI. If the program is too expensive to run compared to the revenue it generates, it might need some adjustments. The goal is to create a program that provides value to clients without becoming a financial burden to the business.
Pick up your copy of "Ultimate checklist: Optimize loyalty program costs" and become the master at calculating expenses.
Your loyalty scheme doesn't exist in a vacuum but it's part of a larger market where competitors are also vying for your customers' attention.
How well does your program differentiate your brand from others?
If your competitors have similar or more attractive loyalty programs, people might not see enough reason to choose yours. That's why it's a big deal to make sure the program offers something unique or better, whether it's more attractive rewards, a better user experience, or profiteering that really sets your brand apart.
People have different preferences for how they like to be contacted. Some enjoy email, while others are more responsive to SMS, WhatsApp, or in-app notifications. A few may still appreciate traditional mail, though it's uncommon now. Catering to these preferences keeps customers engaged.
Timing is everything! Some respond well to a Monday morning reminder, while others might prefer receiving offers on Friday evenings. Getting the timing right can greatly influence how your communication is received.
How often should you reach out to your loyalty members?
Some clients are fine with multiple messages weekly, while others prefer fewer, more detailed communications. Also, what kind of content resonates best: short, punchy texts or more visual and graphic-rich emails? Definitely try to figure it out!
Read more about proper customer segmentation for your loyalty program
Conduct regular audits of your loyalty program. Bear in mind that it's not just about checking standard metrics – you need to assess how well your campaigns and promotions are performing.
Are your campaigns keeping customers engaged and driving the results you expect?
A program without active and engaging campaigns won’t deliver the outcomes you're aiming for. Regular reviews and adjustments are necessary to keep everything on track and ensure long-term success.
Read more on loyalty program audits.
Measuring the ROI of a loyalty scheme can be challenging, but knowing the various models available can simplify the process. In "Loyalty Programs: The Complete Guide (2nd Edition)," you'll find a detailed breakdown of different approaches to help you determine which model is the best fit for your program.
Developed by Brian Wansink, this model is all about saving money while getting better results. The focus is on the rewards offered and their associated costs. Are you spending wisely on the rewards you're providing?
Adjusting how much you invest in rewards can lead to a more viable program without reducing what customers get from it. It's a straightforward way to examine your rewards' costs and find improvement opportunities.
The lifecycle management model takes a broader view of the customer journey, looking at revenue or gross margin. It considers the additional revenue brought in from both new customer acquisitions and keeping existing clients.
Such a business model helps you see the program's impact at different stages of the journey. Are new clients becoming repeat buyers? Are current buyers increasing their spending over time? It gives a complete overview of how the loyalty scheme contributes across different phases of user engagement.
The RFM model is handy for tier-based programs. It segments clients based on how recently they've purchased, how often they buy, and how much they spend.
By breaking members into these groups, you can identify which segments are driving the most ROI. It's a very practical way to understand customer behavior and fine-tune your program for different tiers.
Read more about RFM model segmentation.
The coalition model might be the right fit if your program involves third-party partners. It calculates ROI based on the billings from partners who offer points to their customers, as well as the revenue from points earned, redeemed, and even those left unused.
Use this approach to see the complete financial view in programs that involve partnerships or coalitions, covering both direct and indirect revenue streams from these relationships.
Find out more about coalition loyalty programs and how you can create an engaging open-loop scheme.
The member lifetime model focuses on the revenue members generate throughout their time with your brand.
It looks at direct purchases and the impact of earned and redeemed points. Decide on this approach to get insight into a client's long-term contribution to your business. You'll easily evaluate how the loyalty scheme extends the customer lifecycle and increases their overall spending over time.
The benchmark of ROI for loyalty schemes can vary quite a bit, but to give you a general idea, a well-run program typically sees an ROI ranging from 200% to 400%. This means that for every dollar you invest in the program, you could get back two to four dollars. On average, it takes about 3 to 6 years to achieve this ROI.
Let’s dive into what this looks like across different industries and what factors can impact these numbers.
To sum up, always set realistic expectations. While some programs can achieve extremely high returns, a positive ROI of 200% to 400% is still considered a win-win.
And remember, it might take some time for new programs to build engagement and show significant returns!
Loyalty schemes can have a big impact on your company's revenue by boosting key areas. When done right, they encourage customers to spend more, buy at a higher frequency, and sometimes even pay for premium memberships. Let's break down how programs can influence revenue-related metrics.
Find out more about the 10 best gamification loyalty programs.
Loyalty schemes can indeed be quite profitable when they're thoughtfully designed and properly executed. They enhance customer loyalty, encourage repeat purchases, and provide valuable insights into customer behavior. Now, let's break down how they actually contribute to your business's profitability.
One of the biggest perks of a program is lowering acquisition costs since it's generally cheaper to keep existing audiences than to attract new ones. A well-run program makes people feel valued, which increases the chances they'll stick around and stay loyal to your brand.
Besides, clients in loyalty programs have a higher lifetime value (LTV). They're more likely to spend more, shop more frequently, and be more loyal, which all add up to a stronger relationship and a boost in their overall LTV.
Loyalty programs can really boost how much people spend. For one, they encourage people to shop more often since they're trying to earn those rewards. It's like giving them a delightful reason to keep coming back.
On top of that, they're also perfect for up-selling and cross-selling. When clients see targeted rewards or promotions, they're tempted to add that extra item or spend a little more, which naturally raises the average order value.
Loyalty programs also provide businesses with valuable customer data and insights. They gather information on people's preferences and behaviors, which can then be used for personalized marketing. As a result, companies can send out tailored promotions that feel more relevant, leading to higher conversion rates.
With a better understanding of what clients like, businesses can fine-tune their offerings so that they stock what's in demand. So, If managed well, loyalty programs can boost customer satisfaction, help optimize inventory, and reduce waste.
Loyalty programs are also great for setting your brand apart from the competition and boosting commitment. In fact, when run well, they can foster a real sense of community, strengthening brand loyalty and even turning them into brand advocates.
Also, keeping people engaged through these programs helps keep the brand front and center in their minds, making it less likely that they'll switch to a competitor.
When considering a loyalty program, loyalty managers should think about the cost-benefit aspect. Sure, there are some costs involved in setting up and maintaining these programs, like technology, rewards, and marketing expenses. However, if the program is well-executed, the benefits tend to outweigh these costs.
You can also measure loyalty program ROI by looking at metrics like customer retention rates, how much each buyer is spending on average, and the extra revenue generated from those who are part of the program. This way, you can really see if it's making a positive impact on your bottom line.
Loyalty programs are great for long-term profitability because they help create sustainable revenue growth. Encouraging repeat shoppers provides a steady income stream, making the business more resilient during market ups and downs.
Keep in mind that satisfied loyalty members often spread the word, referring to friends and family. This kind of word-of-mouth marketing can bring in new consumers without the extra cost, adding another layer of revenue.
To create an effective loyalty program, you need to give it constant attention! Focus on creating smart communication strategies, setting clear goals for your campaigns, and checking in regularly to see how things are going. Keep your customers engaged by adjusting based on how they're interacting with the program.
To wrap it up, be sure to calculate the ROI of your loyalty program with a trusted tool and some expert advice before you launch. Trust us: a well-run program can really make a difference!
Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to acquire, engage, and retain your customers
200+ loyalty experts reveal trends, challenges, and strategies you can’t miss.
